I wasn’t sure where I stood on nostalgia when I saw Steve Martin and Martin Short together on the small screen again. And then there’s Selena Gomez who I haven’t seen in anything but I know far too much about thanks to the pervasiveness of celebrity gossip.
Not knowing how I felt about any of it, I decided to click play because I needed something to “watch” while making dinner one night. I figured since I didn’t dislike anyone inherently and the story revolved around murder and true crime podcasts, I was bound to find something to sink my teeth into. And for once, I was right.
Charles (Steve Martin), Oliver (Martin Short) and Mabel (Selena Gomez) are neighbors. They live in the same building and are obsessed with the same podcast. They meet one day on the elevator. I guess “meet” would be a stretching it. They talk to one another and remark on how weird the other guy who got on was, mild neighbor bonding stuff. Then they meet again when the fire alarm in their building goes off and they’re stuck outside. Mabel and Oliver find Charles at a nearby restaurant and that’s when they realize they’re all fans of the same true crime podcast. Having just found other members of their tribe—something that doesn’t appear to happen often for them—they immediately settle in for dinner and the latest episode.
When their paths cross again, the three of them realize that true crime has found its way into their building. The other guy they’d all been on the elevator with yesterday is dead. The cops don’t know who did it, and as far as the three of them are concerned: everyone’s a suspect. Thrilled to be able to solve an actual crime, the thought of doing their own podcast isn’t far behind.
Even if you’re not into true crime or podcasts, Steve Martin is still incredibly charming and witty, Martin Short is still hilarious and Selena Gomez, it turns out, is pretty great. I got hooked immediately and burned through the available episodes way too quickly. And yes, I said available. They didn’t release the entire season in one shot, so be prepared to wait once you’re all caught up.